Pleasanton's Best Pizza

The Best Pizza in Pleasanton: A Local’s Guide to Every Delicious Slice

Looking for the best pizza in Pleasanton? Whether you're a longtime local or house-hunting with Elation Real Estate, one thing is certain—this East Bay gem is home to a surprising variety of top-tier pizzerias. From authentic Neapolitan pies to bold fusion flavors, Pleasanton has something for every pizza lover.

Let’s dive into some of the most beloved pizza spots in town, each with its own unique spin on the classic slice.

1. Locanda Amalfi – A Taste of Naples in Downtown Pleasanton

📍 Locanda Amalfi

If you're craving true Neapolitan-style pizza, Locanda Amalfi is your go-to. Located right in the heart of Downtown Pleasanton, this charming spot serves pizza that's wood-fired to perfection, with a blistered crust, San Marzano tomato sauce, and fresh mozzarella di bufala. Each bite feels like a quick escape to the Amalfi Coast.

Pro tip: The Margherita D.O.C. is a must-try—it’s a classic for a reason.

2. New York Pizza – East Coast Flavor, West Coast Vibe

📍 New York Pizza

Thin, foldable, and bursting with flavor—New York Pizza delivers that unmistakable Big Apple energy. With generous portions and quick service, this is the perfect stop when you’re craving a no-fuss, cheesy slice. Their pepperoni pizza is a fan favorite and hits the spot every time.

Perfect for: A casual night in or post-move celebration when you're still unpacking boxes.

3. Porky’s Pizza Palace – Old-School Goodness Since 1963

📍 Porky’s Pizza Palace

A local institution, Porky’s has been slinging dough since the '60s. Their traditional pizza style, with its thick crust and hearty toppings, is a nostalgic treat. Families love it for the friendly atmosphere and generous portions, and the crunchy, cheesy crust is borderline legendary.

Don’t miss: The house special loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and olives.

4. Gay Nineties Pizza Co. – Historic Charm Meets Epic Flavor

📍 Gay Nineties Pizza

Set in a century-old building, Gay Nineties Pizza Co. combines Pleasanton history with top-notch pizza. Their traditional-style pies are cooked in a brick oven and topped with fresh ingredients. It’s a cozy, sit-down spot perfect for a Friday night out.

Fan favorite: Their Combination Pizza—generous, gooey, and satisfying.

5. Zachary’s Chicago Pizza – Deep Dish Dreaming

📍 Zachary’s Chicago Pizza

When only a deep-dish pizza will do, Zachary’s is where you want to be. Known for their award-winning Chicago-style stuffed pizzas, they layer gooey cheese between two thick crusts and top it all with chunky tomato sauce. It’s indulgent, hearty, and absolutely worth the wait.

Try this: The Spinach & Mushroom stuffed pizza—it’s rich, savory, and a cult favorite.

6. Curry Pizza House & Parktown Pizza – Fusion with a Flavor Kick

📍 Curry Pizza House
📍 Parktown Pizza Company

If you're craving something bold and different, check out Pleasanton’s best Indian-fusion pies. Curry Pizza House and Parktown Pizza specialize in combining classic pizza crusts with spicy, flavorful Indian toppings. From butter chicken pizza to tikka masala pies, these spots bring the heat in all the right ways.

Go bold: Order the Tandoori Chicken Pizza—a perfect marriage of smoky, spicy, and savory.

Final Thoughts

Pleasanton’s pizza scene is as diverse as its community, with each pizzeria offering something deliciously unique. Whether you're into classic Neapolitan, thick Chicago-style, or adventurous curry fusion, there's a perfect slice waiting for you. And for those relocating or looking to call this vibrant city home, great pizza is just another reason to love Pleasanton.

Looking to move to a neighborhood near one of these amazing pizza spots? At Elation Real Estate, we know Pleasanton like the back of our hand—and we’re here to help you find not just the right home, but the right slice of life too.